Where a Howrah cheque bounce case is filed
A Section 138 complaint is filed where the payee's bank branch is situated. For a payee banking in Howrah, that means the court having jurisdiction over that branch within the Howrah district. Filing at the wrong place is not a technicality — it is a ground on which the complaint can fail.
The complaint is made before the Judicial Magistrate, who takes cognizance and issues summons to the accused. Howrah's district judiciary sits at the Howrah court complex, with magistrates handling the metropolitan and district work in the area.
The two deadlines that decide the case
First: the notice demanding payment must be issued within 30 days of the dishonour memo. Second: the complaint must be filed within one month of the day the cause of action arises — that is, after the 15-day period given to the drawer to pay has expired without payment.
Both dates are read from documents: the cheque return memo, the date of despatch of the notice, and the acknowledgement or service proof. If the notice was never delivered, courts have generally allowed a fresh notice and a fresh cause of action, but that is a question of fact each time, not a safe assumption.
Documents to keep ready
The original cheque, the bank's return memo showing the reason for dishonour, the written demand notice, the postal receipt and acknowledgement, the bank statement or ledger extract for the transaction, and a copy of any invoice or agreement that explains why the cheque was issued.
A common weakness in these cases is a file with no proof of the underlying debt. Section 138 is not a summary recovery mechanism; the complainant still has to establish that the cheque was issued for a legally enforceable debt or liability.
What happens after filing
After cognizance, summons issues. On the accused's appearance, notice is framed, the complainant leads evidence on affidavit, and the accused is examined. The case can end earlier in two ways: by compounding, which the Act expressly permits, or by payment with permission to withdraw.
Contested matters take longer, and the sentencing stage matters: on conviction, the court can impose a fine of up to twice the cheque amount and a term of imprisonment. In practice many matters settle at the stage when the accused realises the exposure is a multiple of the cheque.
Mistakes that sink Section 138 complaints
Sending the notice late, sending it without proof of despatch, filing before the 15-day period has run, or filing against the wrong person — for instance against a director without pleading the basis of vicarious liability in a company case. Each of these is curable if caught early and fatal if ignored.
The other recurring mistake is treating the return memo as optional. Without it, there is no evidence of dishonour, and the case cannot proceed.